Did the Bible come from ancient Egypt? What did Massey claim, and what do scholars say?

Not as a whole, say biblical scholars and Egyptologists, though Egypt left its mark in places. The clearest is a passage in the Book of Proverbs that closely parallels an Egyptian book of wisdom. Gerald Massey went much further. In the last six Books of his 1907 book Ancient Egypt: The Light of the World, he argues that much of the Bible, from Genesis to the Gospels and Revelation, grew out of Egyptian myth and ritual retold as history. Scholars see a Bible that took shape in a world it shared with Egypt, Mesopotamia and Canaan, not a copy of Egypt.

Massey’s claim, Book by Book: Massey makes his case in Books VII to XII. In Book VII he reads the creation and the Garden of Eden in Genesis as Egyptian myth, and Adam as the god Atum. In Book VIII he finds Egypt behind the Psalms, Job, Isaiah and Proverbs, whose father-to-son sayings he sets beside the Egyptian Instruction of Ptahhotep. Then he traces to Egypt the ark and the flood (Book IX), the Exodus (Book X), the Revelation of John (Book XI) and the gospel story of Jesus (Book XII). In his reading this was not forgery: an outward version of Egyptian teaching was written down as history, and its key was lost.
A world the Bible shared: Scholars agree that the Bible grew up among neighbours. Hebrew is itself a language of Canaan. The flood story of Genesis is closest to Mesopotamian ones, such as the flood in the Epic of Gilgamesh, where the man who survives it sends out birds to look for dry land. The clearest link to Egypt is in Proverbs: much of Proverbs 22:17 to 23:11 closely parallels the Egyptian Instruction of Amenemope, a father’s teaching for his son, and most scholars think Proverbs drew on it. Both warn, for example, that riches make themselves wings and fly away (Proverbs 23:4 to 5). The Egyptian text was published only after Massey’s death. Psalm 104 is often compared with the Great Hymn to the Aten, the sun disk: both picture lions prowling by night and people going out to work at sunrise. Whether the psalm drew on it is debated.
What scholars say now: Biblical scholars and Egyptologists do not accept Massey’s view that the Bible’s stories, from Genesis to the Gospels, grew out of Egyptian myth retold as history. They read the Hebrew Bible as Israel’s own writings, gathered and edited over centuries and sharing forms and images with the whole region, and the Gospels as Greek writings of the first century or soon after, from a Jewish setting. Many of Massey’s links rest on names that sound alike, or on translations of his day that have since been revised. Scholars do note one likeness he points to: like Egypt’s books of instruction, Proverbs speaks as a father teaching his son. They see it as a way of teaching shared across the region, not as proof of his wider case.
In Massey’s words: “The veil of words in the Hebrew constantly conceals the wisdom of the Egyptians that lies beyond it in the Jewish scriptures, and this is the rending of the veil.” (Gerald Massey, Ancient Egypt: The Light of the World (1907), Book VIII, p. 532)
In the app: Library › Book VII. In the app, Book VII begins Massey’s case with Genesis, and Books VIII to XII carry it through to the Gospels, in his own words, with a plain-words note under every part.

Last updated November 2, 2026.

Next questions

Get it on Google Play